Help Me Redecorate

Well, eating family meals without a dining table couldn't last all that long. I knew it wouldn't, though I can say with gladness that none of us complained or felt distressed by having to eat on the floor, in the living room or at our tiny work table. It's amazing what we can live without and still function well.

That said, we found a great small-business guy on Craigslist and bought a table from him at an astonishingly low price. Granted, it was a store return so it has a few hairline scratches, but I'm so happy to have not bought "new" and support an individual trying to make a living. (He also happens to be a Catholic man who loves the latin mass and has a devotion to St. Peregrine.)

But now I need chairs - we're presently using 3 folding chairs and a step stool. I found this (#1) at a local shop and was able to bring it home to see it next to the table. Call me completely crazy but I love it. If you like your furniture to coordinate perfectly than you won't like this, but I do.

The back of this chair (covered in grain sack) is fabulous!
#2 is similar to #1, but cheaper because we have a gift card to this store, making it the most affordable of all the options.

#3 - the ladderback. I like this a lot, but I'd want to change the upholstery or slipcover the seat cushion.

#4 is very similar to the chairs we used to have, with a little more detail.

Though pictured, I'm not considering arm chairs. Just 4 side chairs for now because that's all we need. So, considering style only - not finish (or the impracticality of upholstery:) - which do you like best?
~